So I’m at brunch the other day with a friend, LT, and her new boyfriend, BF, and halfway through our omelettes she turns to us and goes, “If you were given the opportunity, would you commit ethical cannibalism?”
OK, go ahead and answer that. Remember your answer? Now we continue the conversation.

Me: “Sure.”
BF: “Yep.”
LT: “Really? You’d eat somebody with their consent?”
Uh.
BF: “Oh, is that what you meant? I thought ethical cannibalism was like… you’re on a desert island, you have to eat somebody to stay alive.”
Me: “I thought ethical cannibalism was when the victim deserves it.”
LT: “No, it’s like… OK, first of all Premee, nobody deserves to be eaten.”
Me: “I can think of a couple of people.”
What we had, essentially, was a semantic discrepancy, which is why you should always clarify these things before you agree. (Not that my answer has changed, but we found it interesting that amongst three people we had three different definitions.)
I asked it again in the car the other day:
Me: (very casually) “So if you had the chance, would you commit ethical cannibalism?”
Carpool Boy: “You mean like… if I had been in a plane crash or something and the only way to survive was to eat someone who had recently died?”
Me: “Oh damn, you actually defined it first. So that’s a yes?”
Him: “Well if I was going to die.”
Then on Saturday I asked yet again, over cocktails and dinner:
Me: “Sooooo…if you had the chance, would you commit ethical cannibalism?”
Guy: “Yup.”
Me: “Didn’t give that one much thought, did you.”
Guy: “No need. In fact – ” And here he reached for a fork, presumably in jest, but I still flailed backwards into my side of the booth just in case.
Notice how he didn’t actually define ‘ethical cannibalism,’ thereby depriving me of the chance to add to my running count of definitions. It’s obviously one of those phrases not in sufficiently common parlance to have a universal definition, but we all know what ‘ethical’ means and we all know what ‘cannibalism’ means, so we make up our own on the spot. (Except for Friend #2 there, who doesn’t seem to have a definition for it inasmuch as he regards eating human as not much different from eating chicken or beef, God help me.)
Funnily enough, the consent thing never occurred to me as ethical cannibalism, even though I clearly remembered reading about that German guy who had eaten people he met online, with their consent. I think his consent was chat logs or something, but still – if it’s in writing, and it’s on the internet, you can’t un-say it.
Which got me thinking about the cannibalism taboo, and forgive me for not having done any background reading, but why are people (almost) always squicked out by it? Was there ever a time when you could say you had ‘long pork’ for dinner and have everyone nod instead of screw up their face in disgust? Was there ever a place?
About a year ago, I got a whole pack of hippy-dippy e-books online; I wanted the one about composting and wasn’t able to get it on its own. So as I was scrolling through the other titles (“Stupid, stupid, boring, stupid, boring, as if…”) I ran across one on butchering animals. And I stopped at that one, because one of my cookbooks has good instructions on taking apart a whole chicken but what if I had to do something bigger, like a deer? So I popped it open and yeah.
Butchering humans.
It’s so detailed that I assume it has to be an elaborate joke, but there are no overt traces of humour anywhere in it, and I really looked. And secondly if it is a joke it isn’t a funny one. Because I was sitting there looking at the different cuts going “Wow!” because I am certainly not taboo-free, I subscribe, in fact, to a whole lot of taboos, including some that no one in their right mind would see as a problem, such as eating chewy bacon. (VERBOTEN.) So yes, I have a problem with cannibalism, but I always had it more in the sense of “Please don’t eat me” (which should tell you something about the company I keep) rather than “It bothers me that you are eating him.” But this book, it was… OK, look.

See? Disgustifying. Repulsotronic. I’ve totally lost my appetite and will never eat another human again.
Readers, thoughts on the cannibalism taboo?